The Classics Club Spin Spun me a Sicilian Romance ….

….and I’m very pleased that it did.

I’ve always hoped that I would fall in love with Ann Radcliffe’s novels, with  the coming together of the gothic and the romantic, but I was scared to take the first step and so I needed that spin.

It was love, of course it was.

The opening chapter was wonderfully readable and it set the stage for what was to come. A traveller was struck by a sight on the north coast of Sicily: a ruined castle that had clearly once been grand. He met a monk, he asked him what he knew of the history, and he was guided to a manuscript that told the story of why the Castle Mazzini had been abandoned.


Late in the sixteenth century, Julia and Emilia, the daughters of the first marriage of fifth marquis of Mazzini lived there. They lived with their governess – a poor relation of their mother – and a manservant. Because their father had left, to live in another of his homes, much nearer society, to please his second wife.

They were isolated but they were happy. Until one night they saw a light in a part of the castle that was unoccupied. Until they began to hear noises that they couldn’t explain …..

And then the Marquis came home. His son, Ferdinand, was happy to be reunited with his sisters, and they with them. His wife was not pleased but he placated her by throwing parties, inviting guests.

Why had he come back?

Julia fell in love, with a dear friend of her brother. That did not endear her to her step-mother, who wanted him in her retinue, as a young lover. And her father was planning another marriage for her, a marriage that would be advantageous to him but that would be anathema to her.

Julia rebelled, but that made her – and her supporters – very, very vulnerable.

That was just the beginning of a story that had everything you might hope to find in a gothic romance: family secrets, locked doors, narrow escapes, banditti, isolated monasteries, betrayal, underground tunnels, confused identities, wild weather ….

The characters were simply drawn. Two heroines, one spirited, one quiet, and both inclined to faint. A governess, with a tragic story of her own, who would do everything she could for them. Two heroes, one a brother and one a lover. A tyrannical father. A wicked step-mother. It was predictable, but it worked.

I had an idea where the story was going very early on, and I was right, but I loved the journey though the story, living though it with the characters, hearing the stories that were told along the way.

The descriptive writing was lovely, and it pulled me right into the story. The authors style was lovely too. Her prose didn’t feel dated at all, it felt like classical English by somebody who knew how English should be written and spoken.

I think the logic worked. There were extraordinary coincidence, and of course the story was ridiculous, was predictable, went round in circles – but living through it with the characters, through all of the highs and lows, was wonderful.

I’m glad I came to this book having read some of the great 20th century writers of romantic suspense – Daphne Du Maurier, Mary Stewart, Victoria Holt – because I can imagine that they loved and were influenced by Ann Radcliffe’s writing.

One aspect of the plot even made me think of D E Stevenson.

It’s a particular kind of writing for a particular reading mood, and I could very easily read more of Ann Radcliffe’s writing when that mood strikes again.

12 responses

  1. Oh, I’m so glad you liked this! I love Anne Radcliffe, though I’ve only read The Mysteries of Udolpho. 🙂

  2. I read Castle.of Udolpho and Romance of the forest a long time ago, inspired so think by the refrences in Northanger Abbey, I think I enjoyed them on the whole, but not sure I would feel the same now.

  3. I did not get on at all with The Mysteries of Udolpho – like Ali I read it because of Jane Austen, and that rather put me off Ann Radcliffe. But that was a long time ago – and my reading tastes do tend to change – and you make this one sound very intriguing!

  4. I too read Udolpho a long time ago – so long ago I can’t remember anything about it! But this sounds like a wonderful read, and luckily I have it on Mount TBR!

  5. I simply must read an Anne Radcliffe book soon! She has been on my TBR list for ages. The Mysteries of Udolpho intimidated me with it’s length, so A Sicilian Romance might be a better place to start. Thanks for the great review!

  6. I love Ann Radcliffe, though you do need to be in the right mood for this kind of book! I enjoyed this one and The Mysteries of Udolpho, but my favourite is The Italian.

  7. I am glad you like it!! I loved it too and I was kinda scared as well about reading it because, like you I wanted to really like Radcliffe and was afraid to begin…I too enjoyed the journey some very lyrical descriptions!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: