Since I discovered what a wonderful writer Mary Stewart was – just a few years ago, though my mother had recommended her books many years earlier – I’ve noticed that many readers name ‘Nine Coaches Waiting’ as a particular favourite. Now that I’ve read ‘Nine Coaches Waiting’ I can understand why, and I think that it might be my favourite too.
It’s not a realistic, real-world story; but it is a glorious entertainment
And it’s a ‘governess novel’ – a kind of book that I love
The story begins as Linda Martin lands in Paris on a cold, grey, rainy day. She was the son of an English father and a French mother, but they died when she was still quite young, and so she finished her education and became a governess inside an orphanage.
When the chance of a job in France appeared she was thrilled at the prospect of returning to the country she hadn’t seen for many years, and she secured the position. An English girl had been requested, and so she thought it sensible not to mention that she spoke the language fluently.
I warmed to Linda from the start, and I saw such promise in the story that was unfolding.
Her charge was Philippe, who also lost both his parents in a tragic accident. He was the heir to his father’s title, and to his estates, and he lived in the family home that he inherited, the vast and ornate Château Valmy, in the French Alps.
Linda was enchanted by the house, by its beauty and history, but she also saw that it was not a happy home.
She warmed to Philippe though, and a strong bond grew up between them.
He didn’t care for his Uncle Leon and Aunt Heloise, but Linda told herself that was just because they weren’t warm or demonstrative, because their lifestyle wasn’t suited to being parental figures, because they weren’t his beloved parents …..
Linda is shaken when two accidents, one in the countryside and one at home, come close to taking Philippe’s life. She knows then that something is wrong then, but she doesn’t know who to trust. She only knows that she will do whatever she can to protect Philippe.
She wanted to trust Raoul, the dark and dashing young man who had her utterly smitten, but she knew that he was Leon’s son, and that he might have had a hand in those accidents ….
I’d love to say more, but I mustn’t give away any more of the story than I have already.
But I must say what makes this book so special.
Mary Stewart always evokes the settings of her stories wonderfully well, and in a way that feels so natural; she does that here with the loveliest of settings. I was transported to the big house, to the nearby village, to the countryside. I loved it all.
The cast of characters was wonderful. Linda was plucky – but not too plucky – and I found it easy to understand her feeling and how she reacted to people and situations. Her relationship with Philippe was caught perfectly, and he was an utterly real child; he understood what was happening, but he needed guidance and support; and he needed a friend. The relationship between Linda and Philippe, and the way it evolved, was lovely, and exactly right.
All of the characters were simply drawn; but they had such depth. Uncle Leon was particularly interesting; a strong powerful man, confined to a wheelchair after an accident, and constrained by the role he had to play as his nephew’s trustee …..
The story was perfectly judged; mystery, suspense, romance, and just a dash of the gothic, woven together by a craftswoman at the height of her powers. And there was a nice balance of elements that were recognisably ‘Mary Stewart’ and elements that made this story distinctive. It was full of wonderful details; and I particularly liked the way that the small debt to Jane Eyre was acknowledged.
As events played out I was so caught up, so concerned for Linda and Philippe. I wasn’t sure that she was doing the right thing, but I knew that she was acting was the best of intentions. I could think of no better alternative, and I had no more idea than she did, or who she should or should not trust.
I realised, just a little before she did, that a new governess with no home and no family of her own might be a perfect scapegoat ….
The tension grew and grew. I knew how I wanted the story to play out, but I wasn’t sure that it could.
It did. I think ….
This was only the second of her suspense novels that I read, so I still wasn’t quite sure what to expect from her stories – so she kept me guessing right up to the end (which isn’t actually hard to do with mysteries, I never guess). This one confirmed for me that I’d really been missing out on her non-Merlin books.
I’d read enough of her books by the time I came to this one to have an idea how things would go, but still I wasn’t quite sure until the end. And I was caught in the moment of the story, which has to be a good thing.
You’ve described it so perfectly! I think it is one of Stewart’s best because of the wonderful balance of all her novel’s typical elements. And the governess aspect is just an added bonus.
Exactly! This one has everything you’d look for in a Mary Stewart novel and more besides.
Although I read all her Merlin books in my teens, I still have a pile of her other books waiting to read. This sounds really wonderful, Jane!
I didn’t read the Merlin books, because The Mists of Avalon captivated me and I didn’t think they could live up to it. But I could be tempted to go back now …
This is a wonderful book, isn’t it? It was my first introduction to Mary Stewart a few years ago and still my favourite. I’m in the middle of Madam, Will You Talk? at the moment and loving that one too.
You were one of the people I remember picking this out as a particular favourite, so I’m leased to know you’re loving ‘Madam, Will You Talk?’ too because I have that one still to read.
I’ve not read this one. Sounds wonderful though.
This is definitely the book to go for next time you feel the call of romantic-suspense!
Thanks for this trip back in time–I read this years ago, but your review reminds me how much I enjoyed it. My copy is long gone…and for some reason I don’t see these early ones on the used book market that often. Another title to add to my searches! :o)
This is the only one of Mary Stewart’s romantic-suspense novels that I haven’t managed to pick up in a charity shop or secondhand bookshop, so I read a library copy But I’m still looking, because I’m sure now that I need a copy to keep.
A great review Fleur and you’ve made me want to read it. I read some of Mary Stewart’s novels in my teens and loved them. Time to return to them think. Thank you.
Thank you. Mary Stewart’s books passed me by in my teens, but I am so glad that they were reissued and I decided that it might be time to give them a try.
This is the first Mary Stewart book I ever read…and it’s been my favorite ever since. Linda and Raoul and their romance…it doesn’t get better than that!
No, it doesn’t! I loved the romance and that I really wasn’t sure how things would play out until the very end.
I’ve been looking for books by this author and found one on Open Library. My brother Michael. Thanks for the review of this one.
I really enjoyed My Brother Michael, and I hope you do too. I’m sure you will,
Pingback: May 2014: Classic crime in the blogosphere | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction
I think this is the one I will read for the reading week in September. I am enjoying the Mary Stewart books I have read and thank many a book blogger for introducing me to them.
I can’t remember which you’ve read Jo, but if you’d ask me to pick one for you this would have been the book.
Fleur,I went for this, on your say-so, and a thrilling journey it proved to be. Thank you, when my review gores up it will ping-back here on a credit link!