The Little Stranger by Sarah Waters

A Little Stranger

Sarah Waters’ fifth novel, The Little Stranger, opens in rural Warwickshire in 1947. It is a strange time. War is over, but its effects are still being felt, and the world is changing.

Before the war Hundreds House was a grand place. Dr Faraday remembers visiting as a small boy when his mother was one of a veritable army who ensured things ran smoothly.

But when he is called out to see a sick serving girl he finds things much changed. Colonel Ayres, the head of the house, is dead, leaving his widow, a son, who was badly injured in the war, and a daughter. The army of staff is reduced to a single maid and a charwoman, and the family is fighting a losing battle to keep home and finances intact.

For a long time that seemed to be all that there was, and only the quality of the writing and my faith in Sarah Waters kept me turning the pages.

Then finally the real story began.

The first significant incident happens when the new owners of a neighbouring estate visit. They are ill-mannered, mocking the old-fashioned house and hospitality and boasting of the modernity that they will bring to their own home. But one moment that evening will shock them and change the course of their lives.

Was the cause supernatural, or was it something more prosaic?

That question repeats, as strange things keep happening and the Ayres family crumbles.

The Little Stranger is many things. Yes it is, as billed, a ghost story, and though the haunting is not sustained, there are moments of fear, pain and grief as vivid as anything I have read. It is also a wonderful human drama and a compelling portrait of a country and a class system on the brink of change.

What it lacks though is the colour and flamboyance that made Sarah Waters’ earlier novels so beguiling.

That is in large part down to the narrator. Dr Faraday is a dull an unimaginative middle-aged man, who clings to rational explanations for everything. It’s an interesting – and maybe brave – choice and it is a measure of Sarah Waters’ skill that she makes this work as well as she does.

And there is a twist. Not an obvious jolt, but something much more subtle that changes the way that you look at characters, incidents and possibilities.

It made me want to go back and look at things again, and this could well be a book that has much more to offer with subsequent readings.

And the ending? It’s subtle and could be read in more than one way.

The Little Stranger, though maybe not entirely sucessful, was an interesting path for Sarah Waters to try, and I am intrigued to see where she goes next.

10 responses

  1. I have yet to read a Waters book but I will keep your thoughts in mind when I’m reading her later in case some of her other books start out this way. I was planning on starting with Fingersmith because of Nymeth’s review. Have you read that one?

  2. I agree that this book could offer more on subsequent reading. I have found myself considering it much since reading it and even wrote a follow-up post earlier this week, re-evaluating my original impression.

    Sarah Waters is an incredibly talented writer, who is unafraid of taking risks in her writing and alienating her majority fan-base; I too look forward to what she produces in the future, with anticipation.

  3. I agree with your review, but I’m not sure it is a book I’d like to re-read. I don’t normally re-read books anyway, but this book didn’t appear to have the depth required for a satisfying re-read. She is clearly a very talented author, but this book is no where near as good as Fingersmith.

  4. Very interesting the way you stuck with the author because of your previous reading experience. I do the same thing whether it’s a book or a blog post. It comes down to trusting the author to not disappoint.

  5. Pingback: The Booker Prize Longlist 2009

  6. Pingback: The Little Stranger by Sarah Waters | Semicolon

  7. Pingback: #227 ~ The Little Stranger

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: